The Best Grilled Sandwiches You Will Find in Brooklyn

By: George Adelman

There’s a reason why comfort foods are called so – they are truly comforting, satiating, and they fill both your stomach and heart with love! Speaking of comfort foods, it doesn’t get better than a piping hot grilled cheese sandwich that’s quite possibly oozing with melted cheese.

If you happen to be in Brooklyn, you are in for a real cheesy treat because this famous borough in New York City is brimming with small and cozy cafes and restaurants where you can pick up a delicious grilled cheese sandwich. Take a look at a few places that serve the best grilled cheese sandwiches in Brooklyn, some of which will probably even melt in your mouth!


Mrs. Dorsey’s Kitchen

This is a local favorite with an incredible variety of grilled cheese options on the menu. However, there is one particular number that stands out from the rest and is also one of its most hot-selling sandwiches – Mama Mia!

Mama Mia is an Italian take on a grilled cheese sandwich and is loaded with fresh tomato, basil, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese. The sandwich is toasted with extra virgin olive oil spread, which is homemade, adding a touch of homely love and comfort to it!


Noorman’s Kil

When it comes to the best grilled cheese sandwiches in Brooklyn, one simply can’t help mention Noorman’s Kil, an absolute must-visit restaurant for cheesy goodness!

It’s one of those rare whiskey and cheese bars with probably more than three hundred whiskeys a variety of the ever-tastiest grilled cheese sandwiches on the menu.

If, however, you can’t seem to decide which one to go for, you must try the ‘Karen,’ one of its most popular sandwiches truly loved by the people of Brooklyn! The Karen uses rich sourdough bread with a generous serving of Fromage Blanc, sharp cheddar, Havarti, and gruyere cheese, all of which melts in your mouth and transports you to a dreamy world full of cheese!

The Counting Room

You know what’s better than a grilled cheese sandwich? An exotic cocktail AND a grilled cheese sandwich!

The Counting Room in Brooklyn is the best spot for that, especially during nighttime when you are craving for something cheesy, comforting, and delicious.

There are numerous options on the menu, but the Truffle Grilled Cheese is undoubtedly the best one with amazing toasted bread perfectly combined with light truffle oil, melted Fontana, and an optional serving of ham. As you devour your cheesy sandwich, you can sip your favorite cocktail along with it, washing down those last few cheesy bits.


The Wheelhouse

Fancy creating your own grilled cheese sandwich? The Wheelhouse is the best place to do that! You can be as creative and innovative as you like and build your own signature sandwich with a variety of options to choose from, including ciabatta bread, goat cheese, smoked Gouda, gluten-free bread, and many others.

These are some of the best grilled cheese sandwiches in Brooklyn that you ought to try, as they will definitely want you to keep coming back for more!