The Best Steakhouses In Madison Every Steak-Lover Should Try

By: George Adelman

You know what makes a great steak? A succulent, juice and tender piece of meat that is loaded with flavor, has the minimum amount of fat, allows the steak knife to slide through like butter and gives off mouthwatering aromas that waft all around you! And of course, not to mention the delicious sides that come with it such as roasted garlic mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, corn on the cob or stir-fried veggies, to name a few.

There are many incredible steakhouses in Madison that serve the best kind of steaks which fulfil all requirements of a really good steak, but even so, there are a few that simply take the lead over others! Here are some of the best steakhouses in Madison that every steak-lover should visit and try whenever they are in the city.


Tornado Club Steakhouse

This is quite an old-school steakhouse that offers a supper club vibe with picturesque views and outstanding cocktails! It is a must-visit steakhouse in Madison not just for its meaty and generous steaks, but also the overall dining experience that it offers with its classic interior.

While Tornado Club Steakhouse has a number of specialties, a few options that you ought to try include:

  • Rack of Lamb roasted with mustard, garlic, bread crumbs & mint vinegar
  • Filet au Poivre 10 oz. filet with Cognac mushroom cream sauce
  • Pork Tenderloin pan-fried with tart cherry sauce


Johnny Delmonico’s

Often described as a more ‘state of the art’ kind of steakhouse, Johnny Delmonico’s offers the classic surf ‘n’ turf along with rich, exotic wine in a very club-style setting for all the steak lovers out there.

It has quite an extensive menu ranging from chilled appetizers, hot appetizers, salads, soups, sauces, butter, and of course, juicy and tender steaks!

The steaks at this restaurant are served with demi-glace on the plate, a brush of their delicious herb compound butter and a side of either hash browns, baked potato or garlic mashed potatoes.

A few must-try options include:

  • Tenderloin steak Diane
  • Dry-aged New York strip
  • Dry-aged bone-in rib eye


Prime Quarter Steak House

This is a ‘grill your own steak house’ in Madison that brings you an exceptional dining experience with its unique interior and a tempting menu.

The ‘grill your own’ option is the most popular where you are the chef, and you take the lead. You are provided with an assortment of grilling ingredients that strive to satisfy and tantalize your taste buds.

What makes Prime Quarter Steakhouse one of the best steakhouses in Madison is that you get to complement your steak with a side of perfectly grilled Texas-style toast! Just top of it off with some garlic salt and a brush of melted butter, and experience a delicious explosion of flavors in your mouth!

You should definitely try its:

  • Filet mignon
  • T-bone
  • Teriyaki top sirloin
  • Kansas city strip


Are You Ready for A True Steak Affair?

Steakhouses in Madison truly understand what makes a great steak so prepare for yourself for a heavenly steak affair when you visit some these best steakhouses in Madison!