Jazmin T.
8/8/2025
Found this place on none other than TikTok when looking for pizza places in Key West. They came up several times, and by looking at all the videos, I knew we had to give it a go! The great thing...
Big John's Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(143)
Advertisement
Photos
1103 Key Plz
Key West, FL 33040
Big John's Pizzeria in Key West, FL is a popular eatery that offers a diverse menu of delicious pizzas and other mouthwatering dishes.
With a focus on quality ingredients and a commitment to customer satisfaction, Big John's Pizzeria is a go-to destination for locals and tourists alike seeking a satisfying dining experience.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.5(143)
Anthony J.
1/22/2026
We gave Big John's a redemption order, and while it was technically edible, that's about as generous as I can be. The pizza was doughy and bland, honestly on par with a frozen store-brand pie....
Yellow T.
1/19/2026
Pizza toppings were good but the pizza was burnt ! Not good who wants to eat a burnt pizza at $40 !
Bobbi B.
11/22/2025
Great deals for lunch. Off the beaten path in Key West so there is parking. They have great pizza and also offer by the slice. My husband really liked their Philly Cheesesteak. We have been...
Eddie Coyle ..
9/28/2025
I noticed slightly lower reviews than other pizzerias, but I've noticed Key West reviews shade a bit to the pretentious side. Big John's isn't going to have the latest fashionable mushroom,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement