Nancy's Pizza

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(79)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

527 Auburn Dr
Island Lake, IL 60042
+1 (847) 487-4100
https://nancyspizza.com
Nancys Pizza Island Lake has been delighting pizza lovers since 1971 with our legendary Original Stuffed Pizza and beloved thin crust pies. Whether youre craving a cozy night in with delivery, a quick carryout meal, or catering for your next gathering, we deliver bold flavors made from the freshest ingredients. From cheesy pizzas and hearty pastas to crisp salads and desserts, theres something for everyone. Join our Rewards program and treat yourself to something delicious today!

Reviews

yelp logo
3.5

(79)

Photo of Ken B.
Ken B.
1/26/2026

I ordered a cheese and sausage stuffed pizza from Nancy's and it was delicious. I placed the order over the phone and she was polite and she said the pizza would arrive between 30 and 45 minutes....

Read more on Yelp
Kim C.
1/17/2026

Food was outstanding, deep dish cheese pizza and chopped salad. The salad's are amazing because you can design them your way. I am not a gorgonzola fan but do love mozzarella so, I was able to...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Dave P.
Dave P.
3/23/2025

DON'T make the mistake of even trying Nancy's in Island Lake, IL. I was visiting friends in town and I volunteered to pick up pizza on the way. I used google to find pizza close to their house,...

Read more on Yelp
G W.
7/14/2025

What a disappointment. I used to buy a Nancy's stuffed pizza every Sunday night all Summer long as well as Spring and Fall. That began back in the 80's, and blended perfectly with my then...

Read more on Yelp
Adam T.
6/19/2025

Pizza's good, always delivered fast and hot. Very consistent. However, I don't know who's cutting these pizzas, Ray Charles or Stevie Wonder! They're all over the place!

Read more on Yelp
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

Pizza Hut
Pizza restaurants, Steak and barbecue restaurants

Pizza Hut

Find your nearby Pizza Hut at W156 N8420 Pilgrim Rd in Menomonee Falls, WI. You can try, but you cant OutPizza the Hut. Were serving up classics like Meat Lovers and Original Stuffed Crust as well as signature wings, pastas and desserts at many of our locations. Order online or on the mobile app for carryout, curbside or delivery.
Steak and barbecue restaurants

Bella Via Restaurant & Banquet

Bella Via is a family-owned Italian restaurant located at 431 Temple Avenue in Highland Park, Illinois, serving the North Shore for over 26 years. Known for its authentic cuisine, the restaurant offers a charming, intimate setting where patrons can enjoy homemade pasta, Italian classics, and a diverse selection of exclusive wines and handcrafted cocktails. Generated from the website
Steak and barbecue restaurants

White Cottage Pizzeria

White Cottage Pizzeria, a cherished family-owned dining establishment since 1950, has become a staple in the Chicagoland area, particularly known for its authentic Italian cuisine and legendary pizza. Crafted from time-honored recipes, the pizzeria is celebrated for its rich flavors, crisp crust, and generous toppings, ensuring a delightful experience whether dining in or ordering out. With three locations, White Cottage Pizzeria offers consistent quality in both pick-up and delivery options, making it a reliable choice for patrons. For those seeking a special dining experience, their sit-down restaurant, La Dolce Vita, features an exclusive menu showcasing Old World Italian cuisine, with reservations highly recommended. Generated from the website
United States›Illinois›Island Lake›Nancy's Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement