Alex R.
11/2/2025
An Indianapolis institution. I've been coming to Bagel Fair for years and have never been disappointed! Best bagels in Indy! If you go on the weekends, there will be a line but it moves very...
Bagel Fair
$
Closed
(242)
Advertisement
Photos
1300 E 86th St
Indianapolis, IN 46240
Bagel Fair Incorporated is a 2nd generation family-owned business located in Nora Plaza Shopping Center in Indianapolis, IN. Established in 1975, they are known for their fresh, authentic New York bagels made from a family recipe over 100 years old.
With a wide variety of bagel flavors and cream cheese spreads, Bagel Fair offers a delicious selection of bagel sandwiches and beverages. Their bialys, a unique baked alternative to boiled bagels, are a popular choice among customers. Experience Indy's only real New York bagels at Bagel Fair.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.5242 reviews
Candace T.
10/7/2025
The servers are fine. Attentive and helpful. The place looks very clean. The bagels are no better than those you can buy at a supermarket. Maybe worse than some. I purchased 6 sesame bagels, a...
Riauna C.
10/18/2025
The bagel was soooo good. I got a cinnamon raisin bagel with cinnamon sugar cream cheese. The service was 10/10 they were so nice! I love how you're able to see them make your bagel too the vibe...
Michael C.
10/18/2025
Excellent bagels! Pick up only, there's no seating so be aware. Service was quick and friendly, had a jalapeño bagel with jalapeño cream cheese, excellent!
Denise C.
12/6/2024
Not too many fresh bagel shops in Indiana. I had always wanted to come try this place. It's about 30 plus minutes north of my home. They also close early, 2pm. I got a dozen bagels everything,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement