Chris C.
10/28/2025
Very different kind of cookie but in the best possible way. They look like a hockey puck. I was afraid they would taste like a hockey puck... but instead they were a little firm on the outside...
Cookie Plug
Closed
(37)
Advertisement
Photos
646 Massachusetts Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46204
The Chatham-Arch Cookie Plug bakery in Indianapolis, IN, has the freshest and best cookies the streets have to offer! Our thick and warm cookie stacks are like no other - part cookie, part cake, and part brownie. Inspired by street art, graffiti, and hip-hop, we are baking straight-up gangster indulgences! Whether you are rolling with the classics, like with our OG chocolate chip cookie, or are looking for something more exotic, try our purple haze velvet cookie, or the Smores cookie. We even have the baddest duo in dessert history - our cookie and ice cream sandwich in any of our twelve flavors. We are even servin' up some bomb keto cookie recipes, too! 30+ bakeries in the US and PR! Our Chatham-Arch Cookie Plug bakery in Indianapolis, IN,
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0(37)
Lydia C.
8/1/2025
Not very friendly service or policy. Here's the thing about giant cookie places: I never wanna pay for a giant cookie. They have mini cookies, but you can only pay by the dozen.... Regardless, my...
Latonya H.
10/4/2025
Unfortunately I didn't enjoy this place. The service was good and their packaging is awesome! I got the smaller cookies called plug poppers, they come in this pill bottle looking thing, they had a...
Gwennita W.
7/25/2025
These cookies are fire! Soft, moist, thick and delicious. The shop is cute and the wall graffiti is beautiful. So many cookie flavors it was hard to decide. I wish they shipped to St. Louis....
Thomas G.
1/25/2025
After discovering Cookie Plug some time ago due to the criticisms it received; it became a must visit for me because it was something fun and unique, plus I love cookies! I then began bookmarking...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement