Torri B.
11/20/2025
Wiseguy Lounge is a hidden gem on Mass Ave. It's ducked off in the second entrance to Godfathers Pizza too. So you can get a slice of pizza as big as your face AND get a handcrafted cocktail. We...
Wiseguy Lounge
$$
Open
(145)
Advertisement
Photos
545 Massachusetts Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46204
On Massachusetts Avenue, Goodfellas serves hand-tossed NY-style slices and pies (12", 16", 22") with stone-baked crusts, plus calzones and breadsticks and a full bar. Signatures include the $10 Lunch Special, Tommy "Two Times," Taste of Naples, and 1⁄2-price 12" Mondays. Seasonal outdoor seating, private rentals with a private bar, and the Wiseguy Lounge bourbon list. Dine-in and carryout. Near the Mass Ave Cultural Arts District, Gainbridge Fieldhouse, Old National Centre, and The Athenaeum. Vegetarian options. Events/Catering: office@goodfellaspizzeria.com
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.5145 reviews
Jasmine L.
11/1/2025
Great spot! So cozy! Drinks are incredible and the ability to get pizza makes it the best! Service was quick! I'll be back for sure
Yvette A.
7/11/2025
This is always a go to spot for my hubby and I to come to when craving a good cocktail. We haven't been in a while, so I like to check the menu out as some of the drinks change. The signature...
Sarah M.
10/18/2024
While on a double date, we all popped in here for one cocktail each before seeing a show at Footlite Musicals on a Saturday night. It is easily accessible, while still giving a speakeasy vibe...
Tyanna M.
4/14/2024
I have been to this speakeasy a couple of times now and definitely plan on going back. I really like the laid back vibe and LOVE the big leather couches. The food comes from Goodfellas pizza...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement