Chocolate in the Oven

35 reviews

+1 (908) 268-5571

Website

Photos

Had to come back for the s'mores brownie and this strawberry deliciousness again!

S'Mores Bar! Yes, it is as good as it looks.

53 Bridge St

Milford, NJ 08848

+1 (908) 268-5571

http://www.chocolateintheoven.com

Full service retail bakery….specializing in custom and layer Cakes, Italian pastry, homemade cookies, small batch ice cream, Brownie, Bars, Old-Fashioned Candy, Pastry, Breads, and lots of savory items too! Everything is homemade, from scratch, using the finest ingredients. Serving a full line of espresso drinks using fresh locally roasted beans from Someday Coffee Roasters Many Gluten-Free items are available - just ask us for some great options!

Reviews

4.535 reviews

Dennis M.

6/2/2025

Stopping in here was one the high points of a weekend bike ride up the Canal towpath. They had me at "S'mores," but I also grabbed a Seven-Layer bar to go and enjoyed that one later in the ride....

Read more on Yelp

Steve S.

11/25/2024

The pastries and cookies are 4 star. The cakes are "good" and 3.5 star worthy. The place is overpriced as compared to other quality bakers - so 2 star there. Customer service is mediocre- not very...

Read more on Yelp

Dimpi B.

4/5/2024

Loved their Carrot cake and Almond Orange cake. Def trying it again. Such a great sweet place.

Read more on Yelp

Christina P.

5/20/2024

Chocolate in the oven is our go to for a treat! Their eclairs, rainbow cakes, chocolate bomb cheesecake and other pastries are the best around! It was a given that we would have Cathy and her...

Read more on Yelp

Hannah R.

8/16/2024

Chocolate in the oven has a huge variety of yummy treats. It's hard to make a choice.

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?