Joseph A.
12/30/2025
One of the best Diners around. Good price, great steak sandwich and French dip. Don't recommend the steak wrap. Service is great. It's got the good old, but updated ambience.
Atlantis Diner
$$
Closed
(148)
Advertisement
Photos
350 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795
Atlantis Diner is a welcoming dining establishment known for its fast service and a diverse menu that includes great food options. The diner has earned a reputation for its exceptional coleslaw and delicious desserts. Customers appreciate the friendly and honest service provided by the staff.
With an emphasis on quality and customer satisfaction, Atlantis Diner aims to create a pleasant dining experience for all patrons. Whether stopping by for a quick meal or a leisurely dinner, guests can expect a reliable and enjoyable meal. The diner stands out as a favorite choice in the area for those seeking comfort food.
Generated from the web
Reviews
3.0148 reviews
Rosario S. C.
12/30/2025
The Atlantis Diner located in Babylon is a commendable option for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The Diner maintains a clean and reasonably spacious environment. The staff members are amiable, and...
Alex F.
11/2/2025
Ample menu, attentive service, excellent food, beer and cocktails available, reasonable prices, great ambiance, large portions, plenty of parking and the one thing that I very much appreciate:...
Laura C.
10/31/2025
Good food, good size portions. Get the breakfast or lunch specials to get the best bang for your buck. Service is hit or miss, sometimes slow to check on you. Kitchen prepares table at a time so...
Thomas B.
12/1/2025
I can't say I love it or hate it. The service really depends on who your server is. Some Are good and others not so Good. Location and atmosphere is ok. The food is always hit or miss. Something...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement