Eugene L.
7/10/2025
While strolling through Chelsea Market in the morning, I gave in to my empty stomach and stopped by Sarabeth's for a quick bite. Honestly, judging by all the ropes and line dividers, I figured...
Fat Witch Bakery
$$
Open
(469)
Advertisement
Photos
75 9th Ave
New York, NY 10011
Fat Witch turns old-fashioned recipes into modern day treats for the gourmet palate. She bakes from scratch, in small quantities, and with natural ingredients. Fat Witch casts a spell on taste buds around the world, and welcomes sweet teeth into her store in Chelsea Market.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5469 reviews
Keith R.
12/18/2025
WOW FACTOR? Yes, very attractive bakery. HAVE AGAIN: Cherry tart was very good. I asked for butter for my scone and received butter AND jam for which I was charged an addition $1.50 without being...
LaRae B.
10/29/2025
Ordered a Chelsea Market egg sandwich. The brioche bun was soft and buttery. The egg, cheese, and bacon were good but didn't add a lot of flavor. Service was indifferent, but efficient.
Rickster F.
10/5/2025
Great place to get a small ice tea for $5.25. If you need an extra plastic cup of ice (alone) is $1.50. Fleece me once, shame on you. Fleece me twice... well, not going to happen.
Jenny T.
8/29/2024
Although the seating space is not designed for customers to stay long, the desserts themselves will make you to come back for more.
See a problem?
In these collections
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement