Ken S.
10/13/2025
It is excellent but it has not reopened yet the salads are big and excellent. The quesadillas and wraps a delicious.
Peter Pan Diner
$
Closed
(272)
Advertisement
Photos
999 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Peter Pan Diner is an eating outlet that provides a variety of soups, salads, potato es, vegetables, desserts and beverages. The restaurant serves desserts that include caramel walnut cheese, blueberry and cherry crumb and carrot cakes, as well apple caramel pies and chocolate chips. It offers beef tips teriyaki with saut ed vegetables. Peter Pan Diner also provides marinated sirloin steaks, roast fresh ham and roast prime rib. The restaurant serves grilled chicken saut ed with artichokes, tomatoes, red sweet peppers and mozzarella cheese, salsa and sour cream. It provides Tuscany panini that includes fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, grilled red peppers and balsamic vinaigrette dressing s.
Reviews
4.0272 reviews
Tsz-Cheong C.
5/12/2024
You won't find tinkerbell or Captain hook dining here, but you will find a great cup of coffee and food. The service was Awesome as our server Lauren was outstanding! We had the Peter pan Panini...
Denny J.
5/17/2024
So for my 100th Yelp review I decided to go somewhere magical! What better place than the Peter Pan Diner! Let's begin why this diner didn't get 5 stars from me. This diner, with its cute name...
Louis F.
8/2/2025
Peter Pan Diner had a fire 6 months to a years ago and is not open. No renovations going on. Doesn't look like it will ever reopen
Jennifer H.
1/15/2024
Excellent neighborhood diner! Years ago we used to frequent another diner on Deer Park Avenue but discovered this gem when the other went downhill. Their burgers are so good, juicy and tastes...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement