Brnd D.
11/22/2025
Food - 5 Star Service - 5 Stars Ambiance - 5 Stars The pizza, mans behind that counter, and the experience all great yall needa support ts
Pleasantville Pizzeria
$
Closed
(42)
Advertisement
Photos
34 Wheeler Ave
Pleasantville, NY 10570
Pleasantville Pizzeria, located on Wheeler Avenue in Pleasantville, has been a local favorite for over 20 years. Situated near the Pleasantville train station and the Jacob Burns Film Center, this eatery specializes in thin crust pizza and offers a variety of Italian dishes including calzones, salads, and pasta.
Patrons can enjoy a range of options at Pleasantville Pizzeria, from hot and cold wedges to pizza rolls and hearty Italian entrees. With its convenient location and diverse menu, this longstanding establishment continues to be a go-to spot for delicious and satisfying meals in the heart of Pleasantville, NY.
Generated from their available business information
Reviews
4.042 reviews
Tony B.
11/22/2025
My favorite pizza by-the-slice pizzeria in Mount Pleasant. The taste of the condiments, particularly the cheese reminds me of Joe's pizzeria in Manhattan. It's a straightforward, thin crust, New...
Lynn P.
9/19/2025
The pizza isn't good and the owner is rude and obnoxious. The owner is behind the counter using foul language with children present, it's a very uncomfortable environment. I only gave this place...
Christina Z.
9/2/2022
When you can count the number of toppings on a pizza slice you know something's up. They really skimped on several aspects of the pizza (except the price) - not much sauce, not much (and very...
John H.
12/21/2021
Best pizza. Hands down, for me at least. There are all kinds of pizza out there, most of them I won't touch. I grew up in the Bronx and if you like pizza from the Bronx this place should be on...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement