Advertisement

Advertisement

Hotels
Hotels
Food
Food
Shopping
Shopping
Coffee
Coffee
Grocery
Grocery
Gas
Gas

Stuff-A-Bagel

$
yelp logo
35 reviews
+1 (631) 277-1835
Website

Advertisement

Advertisement

Photos

Rainbow Bagel!!
Rainbow Bagel!!
Cream cheese options!
Cream cheese options!
Storefront
Storefront
Peak inside our bag of our Baker's dozen bagels... EVERYTHING Bagel, BLUEBERRY Bagel, PLAIN bagel seen.
Peak inside our bag of our Baker's dozen bagels... EVERYTHING Bagel, BLUEBERRY Bagel, PLAIN bagel seen.
Empty bins on Black Friday 2022 but QUICKLY refilled!
Empty bins on Black Friday 2022 but QUICKLY refilled!
Everything bagel, sausage, egg & cheese
Everything bagel, sausage, egg & cheese
24 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730
+1 (631) 277-1835
http://www.stuffabagellongisland.com

Specialties

Bagels Breakfast & Lunch Fresh Baked Goods Catering

Reviews

yelp logo
2.535 reviews
Photo of Nicole T.
Nicole T.
3/9/2025

Excellent bagels, super friendly staff and clean store. New owners who took over years ago really got their system running well. We are EI natives and only venture here for weekend bagels over the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Dave A.
Dave A.
12/8/2022

HOLIDAY GO-TO FOR BAGELS on LONG ISLAND! Hanging out in Long Island, NY for Thanksgiving brings a definite change of scenery and atmosphere compared the hustle & bustle of The NYC. The drawback...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Sal P.
Sal P.
6/17/2024

I hadn't been to this store in a few months but it's open early so I gave it a chance. Placed an order by phone at 5:30am to pickup on the way to the beach. The staff person was polite and well...

Read more on Yelp
B P.
1/28/2025

Do not go here. This has been a go to for me and my family for years, even when the new owners came in. I was there one day to order a bagel with cream cheese. The lady was making two bagels...

Read more on Yelp
Kate K.
8/23/2024

Paid over $8 cash for a mini bagel with just tuna. Next time, I learned I should drive up the block to Blue Line for maybe half the price and even better food.

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

First Class Bagels
Eating places, Delicatessen (eating places), Bagels

First Class Bagels

127
•
$
"This is our spot! The food is amazing. The staff is wonderful. The line is always long but worth it and a testament of how great it is."
photo of Laurén M.
Laurén M.
Bagel Biz
Eating places, Delicatessen (eating places), Bagels

Bagel Biz

186
•
$
"Good bagels, used to be better, when I lived here a few years ago, now living in Florida. Could use more seeds on the bagels! 13 for a dozen. I think next time we are in the area, I try a..."
photo of Richard G.
Richard G.
Stuff-A Bagel
Eating places, Delicatessen (eating places), Bagels

Stuff-A Bagel

57
•
$
"Yes its loud at times and yes you do wait a little bit for a toasted bagel but the food is always hot fresh and on point."
photo of William G B.
William G B.
United States›New York›East Islip›Stuff-A-Bagel

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement

Advertisement

  • Get directions
  • MapQuest Travel
  • Route Planner
  • Print your map
  • Get help
  • Search the web
  • Send feedback
Learn more about our mobile apps.
  • Android app Google Play
  • Download on the App Store
  • Download on the Amazon Appstore
  • Enterprise solutions
  • Claim your business
  • Developer resources
  • Jobs
  • Advertise with us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Data and licenses
  • About our ads
  • Do not sell