David B.
9/14/2025
My wife and I first visited The Upper Crust shortly after it opened, and I will admit our experience at that time was less than positive. Recently, after spending the day at the Gettysburg Wine...
The Upper Crust
$$
Closed
(295)
Advertisement
Photos
19 York St
Gettysburg, PA 17325
With an open kitchen and 3 wood-fired ovens, guests can watch the chef prepare the seasonal menu, including wood-fired pizzas. Inspired by Modern American cuisine, the Upper Crust serves simple and flavorful dishes, using regionally sourced ingredients. The bar menu includes original and classic cocktails, a creative wine list, foreign and domestic labels, and craft beers from across the country.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5295 reviews
Katie R.
10/4/2025
The good thing about this restaurant is the variety of pizzas and the handmade crust. It really hit the spot! Unfortunately, it's not worth the hassle of the experience of the restaurant. For...
Rodger S.
9/1/2025
We were very disappointed with our most recent visit. Our intention was to order food from the ribs place that adjoins the restaurant. That's usually possible but wasn't on the particular night...
Toni C.
1/3/2026
Best pizza! We have tried four different pizzas and love them all! Place some free air hockey or skee-ball while you're there!
Nicole C.
8/19/2025
Visited family in PA and we went to the upper crust. It was my second time in years and well it has definitely changed. We were a party of 5 and we seated ourselves. It took a while for a server...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement