We stop by quite often during their open season. (April-December). Never been disappointed!
12/30/2023
Never had a bakery item from Toasty Oven hat I didn’t love. Everything is fresh and delicious. Thei...
Toasty Oven Bakery-Amish
Closed
(10)
Advertisement
Photos
Kiel Rd
New Holstein, WI 53061
Toasty Oven Bakery-Amish is a quaint bakery nestled in the heart of New Holstein, WI, known for its delicious baked goods. Specializing in traditional Amish recipes, this bakery offers a variety of pastries, breads, and desserts that are made fresh daily.
With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, Toasty Oven Bakery-Amish provides a welcoming environment for customers to enjoy a sweet treat or pick up a loaf of homemade bread. Whether stopping in for a quick snack or ordering a custom cake for a special occasion, this bakery is a beloved local gem for all to enjoy.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
5.010 reviews
Yummy!
11/7/2021
Worth the stop...Amazing jellies and jams..The best cherry turnover I've ever had. And they are only...
A great place!
3/5/2021
Tasty baked goods, preserves and even doggie treats! I go there frequently and have always been mo...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement